The Silent Thief of Joy: How Overthinking Fuels Nurse Burnout
- Heather Strand
- Sep 5
- 3 min read
Updated: Oct 27
By Heather Strand: Mindset Fitness + Self-Leadership Coach
I used to think being a good spouse, family member or friend meant always having it together. But the truth? My mind was constantly racing—replaying conversations, worrying about tomorrow, planning 27 steps ahead… …all while I was trying to remember if I actually put the laundry in the dryer or just thought about it!
Overthinking is sneaky. It doesn’t show up as a loud problem or alarm. Instead, it quietly steals joy, presence, and connection—while we’re convinced we’re “being responsible” or “staying ahead.”
_________________________________________________________________________
The Cost of Overthinking
You might recognize it:
Catching up with your sister but mentally going over tomorrow’s to-do list
Eating dinner with your spouse but secretly critiquing your to-do list.
Listening to a friend’s story while your brain is already 3 steps into “what if this goes wrong?”
Overthinking is like a silent thief… one that doesn’t steal money or snacks, but somehow your attention—the very thing your loved ones need most.
Even when you’re physically present, your heart and mind are somewhere else. And your loved ones notice. They sense it in your half-smile, distracted nod, or the pause before you respond (or the sigh when you say, “Uh-huh… sure…” for the fifth time in a row).
_________________________________________________________________________
Why Overthinking Feels “Necessary”
Here’s the tricky part: overthinking often feels productive. We tell ourselves:
“If I plan everything perfectly, nothing will go wrong.”
“If I prepare for every scenario, I’ll avoid mistakes.”
“If I overthink, I’m being responsible and caring.”
But instead of creating safety or control, overthinking usually leads to stress, guilt, and missed moments. It’s the classic case of good intentions with unintended consequences—and a touch of “I really need to chill.”
_________________________________________________________________________
Mindset Shifts to Take Back Your Presence
The good news? You can train your mind to stop stealing your joy and start showing up fully. Here are three mindset shifts that help:
1. Notice the Noise
Awareness is the first step. When you catch your mind spiraling into “what ifs,” simply pause and say, “This thought isn’t helping me be present right now… thanks, brain, but I’ll pass.”
2. Anchor Yourself in the Moment
Use your senses to ground yourself: feel the warmth of a hand, hear the laughter of a child, notice the colors around you. This isn’t just mindfulness—it’s presence practice. Bonus: it’s a free, instant upgrade for your family karma.
3. Give God the Thoughts You Can’t Control
Faith reminds us that we aren’t meant to carry everything alone. Philippians 4:6 says: “Do not be anxious about anything, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God.” Hand over the worries, the “what ifs,” the endless analysis—and step fully into the moment God has given you.
_________________________________________________________________________
The Joy That Comes From Presence
When you practice these shifts, something magical happens:
Conversations become richer.
Laughter is deeper.
Time with your loved ones feels lighter and more meaningful.
You’ll start to notice that the most beautiful moments in life aren’t perfectly planned—they’re lived fully and freely. And sometimes, they’re hilariously imperfect, like stepping on a LEGO in the middle of the night… and laughing about it with your kids later.
_________________________________________________________________________
A Small Practice to Start Today
Try this simple exercise:
Pick one daily interaction (dinner, bedtime story, or coffee chat).
For the entire interaction, commit to noticing every word, every laugh, every gesture.
When your mind wanders, gently bring it back—no judgment, just gentle redirection.
Even ten minutes of undistracted presence can shift your day—and your relationships.
_________________________________________________________________________
Final Thought
Overthinking may be silent, but it doesn’t have to steal your joy. You can reclaim your attention, your time, and your connection with the people you love most.
Your family and friends don’t need a perfect or busy version of you—they need the present, fully engaged you.
If overthinking is stealing your joy, I’d love to help you develop tools to quiet your mind, reclaim your presence, and fully enjoy the people you love.
_____________________________________________________________________
Heather Strand | Mindset Fitness Coaching
Comments